Tony, how could you possibly think that post might be inappropriate for this thread? BTW, thanks for sharing.
Hunter,
In some forums/threads if you gore someone's sacred cow even by accident, you will pay for it, so I'm gun shy when I make a long post that may do that.
To test the waters or to demonstrate the point, I'm going to make a post here that may or may not do just that. If it does, please let me know and I will delete the post, or you can do it for me.
My introduction to rifle tuning.
One day at the Laughlin AFB range in Del Rio, Texas, (yes, the same Del Rio you hear about on the border), I was shooting a 700 Remington chambered for 7 mm mag. I kept shooting my reloads but nothing was working. When I say working, I was expecting MOA accuracy but wasn't getting anything close to it.
Finally, a guy came over and asked me what I was doing. He must have seen the frustration on my face.
I told him this brand-new rifle just will not shoot. He asked to have a look, I said sure and handed him the rifle.
He took a piece of paper and ran it down the barrel channel and before he finished, I told him. Done, done, that and it is completely free floating. He looked at me and said, "son that could be your problem".
That surprised me. I thought free floating was best for accuracy and told him so. He barked back you don't understand. Free floating may be best for day-to-day consistency but not necessarily for precision accuracy. That confused me even further.
He then pulled out a match book, the paper kind used to light cigarettes, tore off the cover. Folded it twice and slid it between the barrel and stock forearm. Handed me the rifle and said try it now. I did. Believe it or not, I shot my first sub one inch group with that rifle.
Since then, I've spent an extraordinary amount of time and money chasing the "tune" on rifles. I've read all the threads, participated in many of them, and cringed with some of the things being passed off as the "right way to tune a rifle".
In rimfire there has been people that argue that it is one thing to "tune" a rifle and another thing to make it "shoot."
All I've ever wanted is for the rifle to hit where I aimed. Call it what you like. Doesn't matter to me.
A long time ago I came to my own truth about tuning. It has very little to do with turning that thing on the end of the barrel and a lot more to do with ensuring "all" the components of the rifle are preforming and working as they should. This includes stock bedding, trigger adjustment, trigger timing, ignition, scope bases secured, scope level, ammo load selection, and precision assembly, or ammo lot selection.
When all of these things are right you still have the nut behind the bolt. If he, or she, isn't on their game none of the rest of it matters.
TKH