I'm in the same boat, and ultimately decided that the NP-R2 would work, but was not optimal for holding off in windy conditions because of the 5 MOA distance between stadia line on the horizontal cross hair.
That having been said. the first question you need to ask is whether you hold off for wind or dial everything on the scope. If you dial wind by changing the scope setting every time, then a simple uncluttered target dot is probably fine. If you hold off, then I think a reticle with horizontal hashmarks is critical to doing so consistently.
I greatly prefer the NP-R1 reticle (1 MOA on teh vertical and 2 MOA on the horizontal), but it is only being offered currently in the NSX scopes (1/4 MOA adjustments), not the BR scopes (1/8 MOA adjustments).
I talked with nightforce at SHOT about putting the NP-R1 in the BR scopes and they said "Maybe" if there is sufficient demand for the reticle in the NSX scopes they will eventually offer it in the BR scopes. I mentioned they may get more demand for the reticle if they updated their site to include the NP-R1 in the descriptions of offered reticles (I have the NP-R1 in my 5.5-22x50 NSX and have owned it for over a year - give me a break!!!).
your milage may vary.
JeffVN