Regrettably . . .
Might help to know which one, there are a few variations...
George is correct - there are many variations of the [so called] Robinett reamer out there.
If it is a true (original) version, the maximum case length should be 1.510" - and trim to 1.500". In my opinion, any reamer, ground with a single deviation from the/an original print, should not bear the same title - it's DIFFERENT.
Wayne points out a very good method for determining what you've really got. If you have, or have access to a bore scope, this is sure-fire. You can, assuming it was cut with the chamber reamer, also use your shoulder bump gauge, as opposed to chambering - then, you do not need to drill a hole - simply enter through the gauge-bore, and see what you've got.
Another, more complicated method: 1) trim a case (or two) only just enough to square the mouth(s) - something longer than 1.510"; 2) assure that the shoulder is short of the proper head-space length; 3) disassemble the bolt (remove the firing-pin & spring assembly) and chamber the empty, un-primed case, and see if the bolt will close of only the handle weight. If yes, your chamber longer. If no, your case is too long, and being held against the chamber-mouth chamfer: trim off another 0.005 and repeat, until handle will just close of its own weight. Once the maximum length is determined, trim to 0.010" shorter, then, moniter, and trim all cases when one reaches about 1.505" long, which will normally, be quite a few firings.
Sincalir International makes a "plug-gauge" which works in similar fashion, but the rim needs to be turned down to something smaller than the chamber neck-diameter. RG